I had a chance to see the documentary Restrepo today. It is about the current war in Afghanistan and it follows one US Battle Company for 15 months - from its deployment in 2007 to its leave - in the Korangal Valley in eastern Afghanistan. Is it great film-making? Probably not. However, this provides a unflinching look at the Afghan war (and the war, in general) and I really liked it. It is made by war photographer Tim Hetherington and author Sebastian Junger - who followed the Company for 15-months. There are many fire-fights in the film, as this Company came under fire almost daily. But these fire-fights are real and not staged or acted. It is an haunting film. There is no real narrative arc (apart from the 15-month duty of the Company) nor is there a voice-over from the director. Instead, you only get to hear the voices of the soldiers.
There are many ways to talk about the film. But I will make only couple of points here: It is interesting that we (and the US soldiers) never see the enemy fighters. They do shoot at the targets, but apart from one instance, they don't see the individual they are shooting at. This is perhaps the nature of the modern war that even when you are face-to-face, you can't see the face of the enemy.
For me the most fascinating part of the film was the meeting of US soldiers with the local Shura of the elders. The elders were all very old - and the US soldiers were all very young. In fact, there is a whole lifetime written on the faces of the elders. Most elders had long beards, red with henna, and many of them with only a few teeth left in their mouths. These shura sessions in the film highlight the communication gap between the US troops and the local Afghans - and one of the reasons why the war has been going the way it has been going.
If you are interested in understanding the Afghan war (not necessarily the politics behind it), or if you want to see the impact of such conflicts on individuals, or if you want to have some idea of the tough terrain at the Afghan-Pakistan border, then check out Restrepo.
Here is the trailer of the film:
What is Irtiqa?
Irtiqa is Salman Hameed's blog. A few years ago (before Facebook killed many of the blogs), it used to track stories of science & religion, especially those related to Muslim societies. That is still one of its foci, but now it dovetails more of Salman's interests including film, astronomy, science fiction, and science outreach in both Pakistan and the US.
Irtiqa literally means evolution in Urdu. But it does not imply only biological evolution. Instead, it is an all encompassing word used for evolution of the universe, biological evolution, and also for biological/human development. While it has created confusion in debates over biological evolution in South Asia, it provides a nice integrative name for this blog. For further information, contact Salman Hameed.
The blog banner is designed by Muhammad Aurangzeb Ahmad. You can find all his creative endeavors at Orangie.
Salman Hameed
Salman is an astronomer and Associate Professor of Integrated Science & Humanities at Hampshire College, Massachusetts. Currently, he is working on understanding the rise of creationism in contemporary Islamic world and how Muslims view the relationship between science & religion. He is also working with historian Tracy Leavelle at Creighton University to analyze reconciliation efforts between astronomers and Native Hawaiians over telescopes on top of sacred Mauna Kea in Hawaii. He teaches “History and Philosophy of Science & Religion” with philosopher Laura Sizer, and “Science in the Islamic World”, both at Hampshire College. Salman and Laura Sizer are also responsible for the ongoing Hampshire College Lecture Series on Science & Religion, and you can find videos of all these lectures below. Contact information here.
LABELS
- Arab Spring
- art
- Astronomy
- Astronomy Pictures from Pakistan
- atheism
- beliefs of scientists
- Catholic Church and science
- creationism
- education
- education in muslim world
- ethics morality and science
- evolution
- faith and medicine
- film theater and television
- Friday Journal Club
- general
- history
- humor
- intelligent design
- Irtiqa Conversations
- Islam and Modernity
- islam and science
- Islamic Calendar
- islamic creationism
- Judaism and science
- media
- Muslims in Europe
- off topic
- Pakistan
- politics of science and religion
- posts by Nidhal Guessoum
- primates
- pseudoscience
- religion and environmentalism
- Religion and Health
- Religion and Technology
- Saturday Video
- science and Native religions
- science and religion books
- science fiction
- science in muslim world
- science of belief
- science of morality
- science religion and terrorism
- UFO religions
Blog Archive
-
▼
2010
(309)
-
▼
September
(23)
- Gliese 581g: An extrasolar planet sitting in a "ha...
- Restrepo: An unflinching look at the Afghan war
- Is money the answer for universities? The Pakistan...
- Students in the Arab World Today
- How do students at elite Pakistani universities vi...
- Lunacy still reigns at the Texas Board of Education
- The Daily Show on Religious Conflict
- "Gorillas and God" - Science & Religion Lecture on...
- Muslim Humanoid Robots
- A new book on Al-Kindi's works
- Lynchings in 21st century?
- On Roswell and the Moon Landing Hoax
- IMANA ethics symposium at Hofstra University
- God, the Universe, and French Scientists
- Poverty and Religiosity
- The Simpsons on PhDs and grad students
- Creationism at 35,000 feet
- A New Yorker article on Francis Collins
- The eye of the (religious/atheist) beholder
- Hawking, God, and the Universe
- Off-topic: A smart New Yorker piece on Pakistan
- Astronomy and World Heritage
- Conservapedia on "Counterexamples to Relativity"
-
▼
September
(23)
3 comments:
I saw it last week and agree with your assessment. Very bleak. I thought the fact that there was no real narrative arc was symobolic of the lack of direction (or constantly changing direction) of the war in general. At the end, all I could say is: "what's the point?"
Yes, I think you are absolutely right about that - especially at the time of the filming (2007) - when the Iraq war was spiraling out of hand.
The Afghan war seems to be heading for a stalemate between the 21st century army with modern equipment and a 19th century army that knows the terrain (this is not meant as a compliment to either - but simply an observation). The geo-political situation is insanely complex over there - and perhaps that is the best we can hope for at present.
By the way, also check out this Slate article on Bob Woodward's new book.
very true that what happens in the military!
Post a Comment